If you're looking for a modern, amenity-rich community that offers relaxed, resort-style living in a laid-back setting, Naples Reserve may be just what you're looking for. Tucked off U.S. 41 in South Naples, Florida, this vibrant master-planned community is designed around a large, private lake and offers everything from new construction homes to family-friendly amenities and waterfront views.
Here’s a full breakdown of the pros and cons of living in Naples Reserve, including background information and what to know if you're buying a home in Naples.
A Brief History of Naples Reserve
Naples Reserve was developed by iStar beginning in 2015, with a vision of creating a coastal-inspired, resort-style community focused on active living, lakefront amenities, and natural beauty. Built around 125-acre Eagle Lake and dozens of smaller lakes, the community includes over 1,000 homes across a variety of distinct neighborhoods, with builders like Stock Development, D.R. Horton, Ashton Woods, and KTS Homes.
Designed for both year-round residents and seasonal homeowners, Naples Reserve offers a tropical, Key West-style aesthetic and emphasizes outdoor enjoyment, wellness, and community connection. Learn more about Naples Reserve HERE
Pros of Living in Naples Reserve
1. Resort-Style Amenities
One of the biggest draws to Naples Reserve is its clubhouse and amenity complex, which includes:
-
A stunning resort-style pool with lap lanes and cabanas
-
Indoor/outdoor lakefront café (Latitudes)
-
Tiki bar with fire pit and sunset views
-
Fitness center, yoga lawn, and beach volleyball courts
-
Tennis and pickleball courts
-
Dog parks, walking trails, and a kids’ playground
The Outrigger Center also provides kayaks, paddleboards, and electric boat rentals for residents to enjoy Eagle Lake.
2. Lakefront Lifestyle
Naples Reserve is centered around Eagle Lake, with many homes offering direct lakefront views and access. There are private lakefront beaches, a community dock, and scenic water features that give the entire neighborhood a peaceful, tropical vibe.
3. Newer Homes & Modern Design
With homes built primarily in the past 8–10 years, the architecture in Naples Reserve is fresh, clean, and coastal in style. Many residences include open floor plans, impact glass, quartz countertops, and contemporary finishes.
4. Great for Active Residents
From fitness classes and pickleball tournaments to kayaking and food truck nights, the community is designed to keep residents engaged and connected. It’s ideal for buyers looking for an active lifestyle in Naples, Florida without the formality of a golf community.
5. No Golf Course = Lower Fees
Unlike many gated communities in Naples, Naples Reserve does not include a golf course, which keeps HOA fees more affordable. For those who prefer a social and recreational lifestyle without the added cost of golf club memberships, this is a big plus.
6. Pet- and Family-Friendly
Naples Reserve is welcoming to pets, families, and all age groups. The community design encourages outdoor living, with walking and biking trails, dog parks, and social events for all ages.
Learn more about Naples Reserve HERE
Cons of Living in Naples Reserve
1. Farther from Downtown Naples
Located in South Naples, Naples Reserve is about a 20–30 minute drive to Downtown Naples and the beaches. If proximity to 5th Avenue South or Old Naples is a top priority, this location may feel a bit removed.
2. Limited Walkability to Shops
While the community itself is walkable, you’ll need to drive to reach grocery stores, restaurants, and shopping centers. It’s not a mixed-use development with on-site retail or dining beyond the clubhouse café.
3. New Construction Premium
Because it’s a newer community with modern amenities and high demand, home prices in Naples Reserve have steadily increased. Buyers should expect to pay a premium for lake views or fully upgraded models.
4. Smaller Lots Than Custom Estates
Compared to communities like Pine Ridge or Livingston Woods, homes in Naples Reserve sit on smaller lots. While landscaping is thoughtfully designed, buyers looking for acreage or larger outdoor areas may prefer other options when buying a home in Naples.
Learn more about Naples Reserve HERE
Is Naples Reserve Right for You?
If you're searching for a laid-back, lakefront community with modern homes and resort-level amenities, Naples Reserve is one of the top lifestyle communities in Naples, Florida. It's an excellent fit for families, retirees, and second-home owners who want a newer home, strong resale potential, and an active, pet-friendly atmosphere—without the cost of country club living.
However, if walkability, proximity to downtown, or ultra-private estates are at the top of your list, there are other Naples neighborhoods that may be a better fit.
Interested in learning more about homes for sale in Naples Reserve?
As a local Naples real estate expert, I’d be happy to guide you through available homes, builder options, and help you decide if this community is the right match. Contact me here for a private showing or more information.
