Pros and Cons of Living in Pelican Bay, Naples, Florida

Pros and Cons of Living in Pelican Bay, Naples, Florida

  • 06/17/25

Pros of Living in Pelican Bay

1. Private Beaches and Gulf Access

Pelican Bay is one of the only communities in Naples offering exclusive private beach access. Residents enjoy nearly three miles of pristine white sand, accessible by community trams and boardwalks. Beachfront dining at The Sandbar and Marker 36 adds to the luxury.

2. World-Class Golf and Tennis

The private Club Pelican Bay features a 27-hole championship course designed by Arthur Hills. Residents can also enjoy tennis at multiple Har-Tru courts, professional instruction, and active leagues.

3. Resort-Style Amenities

Pelican Bay’s two community centers offer state-of-the-art fitness facilities, spa services, wellness programming, art classes, and social events throughout the year.  Learn more about the amenities in Pelican Bay HERE

4. Cultural and Shopping Convenience

The neighborhood borders Waterside Shops—home to luxury retailers like Gucci and Louis Vuitton—and is next door to Artis–Naples, Southwest Florida’s hub for performing arts, music, and exhibitions.

5. Beautiful Landscaping and Natural Spaces

Miles of walking and biking trails wind through Pelican Bay’s lush landscaping and mangrove preserves. Wildlife sightings and peaceful green spaces make daily walks extra special.


Cons of Living in Pelican Bay

1. Higher Price Point

Homes in Pelican Bay range from luxury high-rise condos to multimillion-dollar estates. Expect higher HOA fees and additional costs if you join the golf or beach clubs.

2. Seasonal Crowds

During peak season (November–April), the private beach facilities, restaurants, and golf course can become quite busy.

3. Exclusivity

Pelican Bay is a residents-only community, meaning many of the amenities are not accessible to guests or the public. This creates a strong sense of privacy but may feel limiting for some.

4. Car Dependency

While the community offers trams and shuttles to the beach and amenities, residents still need a car for most errands and access to downtown Naples or the airport.


Real Estate in Pelican Bay

Pelican Bay features a variety of real estate options including:

  • High-rise condos with Gulf views

  • Villas and coach homes with golf course or preserve views

  • Single-family homes in private enclaves like Bay Colony

  • Luxury estates with custom architecture and gated access

  • Learn more about the real estate options in Pelican Bay Here

Whether you're seeking a seasonal retreat or full-time residence, Pelican Bay offers an array of home styles to match your lifestyle.


Final Thoughts

Pelican Bay offers a rare blend of coastal living, resort-level amenities, and cultural access, all within one of Naples’ most desirable zip codes. It's ideal for buyers who value exclusivity, convenience, and an active lifestyle—but it does come with a premium.

Thinking of buying in Pelican Bay?
Let’s chat. I can help you compare communities, explore off-market opportunities, and navigate club fees and HOA regulations.

Explore Pelican Bay Homes Now →

📲 Thinking About Moving to Naples?

Let’s find the neighborhood that fits your lifestyle.
Contact Jamie or Explore Naples Neighborhoods HERE

Let us help you find your perfect home and guide you through the relocation process. From new developments to waterfront estates, we specialize in finding homes that match your lifestyle.

➡️ Contact us today to start your Naples, Florida home search.
🌐 naplesjamie.com | 📲 239-248-7558 | Premier Sotheby’s International Realty

Work With Jamie

Jamie specializes in luxury residential properties throughout Naples’ most exclusive and sought after communities. Whether you are looking for a new home or thinking about selling your current home, call me today.

Follow Jamie on Instagram